
Organizational design
Finding the Value Your First Plan Missed
By year five of a private equity hold, the easy wins are gone. The value that’s left sits in the organization, the supply chain and the technology.
I spent most of my career in private equity, so I know the excitement of writing a value creation plan at the deal stage. You’ve got four or five initiatives that look amazing and an arrow on a slide pointing in the right direction.
Then, three to six months after close, sometimes sooner, your attention moves to the next deal. Maybe you’ve hit two or three of them, or gone wide without going deep. The work turned out harder than it looked, and you can only learn so much during diligence. Three years in, you’re at 70% or 80% of the EBITDA you planned.
Governance slips, too. The plan lived in the deal memo and the business case. It got talked about for six months after close, then slid off the agenda as new priorities came into focus. Nobody’s tracking the original plan anymore.
Why the first plan isn’t enough now
Ten years ago, the original value creation plan worked fine. You bought a company, made an add-on acquisition or two, combined a couple of key roles and offices, and transitioned everyone to one system and process. That was enough to sell at a great multiple, and the sponsor and the management team both went home happy.
Today, buyout firms hold companies about seven years before they exit, up from an average of five to six years between 2010 and 2021, according to Bain (opens in a new tab). Rates are high, policy keeps shifting and Bain counts around 33,000 unsold portfolio companies (opens in a new tab).
With that many companies waiting to sell, you’re not getting the multiple you planned on. If you exit at 11 times EBITDA instead of 14, the difference has to come from growing EBITDA itself.
The second look
This is second-tier value, the kind that rarely makes the first plan. A deeper look finds ways to earn revenue more efficiently, sets the company up for growth and keeps building a stronger business before the sale. I always look in three places:
1. The organization
One client, an online bank five or six years into its hold, was moving most of its customer service to a nearshore site through outside agencies. The savings were coming in, but nobody had planned for the rest of the organization.
Managers and directors suddenly had few or no direct reports. Instead of managing people, they were managing an agency. The company also needed far fewer recruiters and HR business partners.
We came in mid-flight and worked with the management team to rebuild the middle of the organization without disrupting customers or compliance. Each manager now oversaw two to four times as much work as before, because the agencies brought their own supervisors.
Some established leaders had done really good work in roles that no longer made sense, so we looked for ways to reposition them. Ten percent of managers moved into new roles, and 17% left the organization. People and dollars moved into parts of the business that could help it grow.
The plan was sound, but nobody had worked out what it meant for the people who stayed. Finishing that work gave the company a structure built for where it was going.
2. The supply chain
The second place to look sits outside the org chart. The COVID-19 pandemic threw supply chains into two years of chaos. After they settled, tariffs arrived and the rules seem to change overnight while court cases play out. The usual fixes, like lining up a backup supplier or asking vendors to bid again, can’t move that fast.
Plenty of businesses put their hands up and raise prices to get through the unpredictable times. Companies that prepare have more levers to pull. With a vendor in East Asia, you can hold product in a bonded or nearshore warehouse while a tariff works through the courts, then bring it into the U.S. when the window opens.
Other levers sit in the contract and the product: who pays tariffs under a purchase agreement, whether a part can use a different resin or less material, and the mix of domestic and international vendors.
One client used several of these levers at once. Parts and materials with short lead times were ordered in larger quantities when a tariff window opened. Those with long lead times were ordered early, held in bonded warehouses and released into the U.S. when the window opened. Where it made sense, the company switched to U.S. vendors or changed a part, using a different resin, for example, so it could buy from countries with lower tariffs. That didn’t erase the tariffs, but together with a modest price increase, it protected the margins the company expected.
Raising prices is one way to adjust; preparing for the swings can turn the same disruption into an advantage.
3. Technology that fits
The third place to look is technology, and AI comes up in every conversation, usually as a magic wand. At a digital security company with a large customer service team, the push was to replace the team with AI. But consider who’s calling: a customer whose identity was just stolen, with their 401(k) in jeopardy, doesn’t want to talk to a bot. So the bot handles login and verification, then hands the customer to a person who can walk them through what happens next.
The same thinking applies on a production line. At a pharmaceutical manufacturer, we looked at inline cameras and sensors that flag a bad batch on the spot. Without them, the problem surfaces two days later and the company scraps hundreds of thousands of dollars of material.
We decide on people and technology together: where the business needs human oversight and where technology plays a specific role that supports the business.
By year five, the low-hanging fruit is gone, and the value that’s left takes more work to find.
How we get there
Finding that second-tier value takes time with people. You can drop any org chart into an AI tool and get a list of cuts. We use those tools as well, and what they produce is a starting point for a conversation with the team: Tell us about your people and the processes they run. Sometimes a manager with only a few reports turns out to have a very good reason for it.
On an organizational design project right now, my team held 62 conversations in the first five weeks, and many people will hear from us three to five times. We move through the organization in a W: leadership first, down to the next layer, back up to check alignment, then down and up again.
All of it runs through the leadership team, so they own the result. And typically the client has the answers—our job is to help them act on them.
Being a neutral party matters, because two fair goals meet in this work. The sponsor needs more EBITDA. The management team has spent four or five years absorbing new owners, new systems and new leaders, and nobody there wants to hear “do more with less.” We sit between them, and between functions, so the CFO and the COO don’t have to fight over whose team changes.
What’s left to find
That work pays off twice when it’s done with the people who run the company. The sponsor banks the savings and heads toward exit stronger. The team inside gets a company that’s moving forward and still a good place to work.
Start with one portfolio company. Prove it. Scale on your timeline.
Tell us which one is behind plan and what the model assumed. You’ll talk to someone who has done the work.
Talk to an advisor